Chapter 44: Worth the Cost
Chapter 44: Worth the Cost
River otters were my favorite animals, which was not information I distributed casually. Favorite things became weaknesses the moment other people learned them, especially when the favorite thing in question had round ears, clever paws, and a documented tendency to float on its back while holding hands with someone it trusted so neither of them drifted away. There were limits to how much emotional evidence I was willing to provide against myself, and the Winter artisan responsible for the otter on the highest shelf had apparently dedicated their career to violating all of them.Its brown fur looked impossibly soft beneath the lanternlight. The stitched paws curved inward as though waiting to hold something, while the enchanted blue ribbon at its neck brightened in slow pulses that resembled a heartbeat. It sat among crystal foxes, snow owls, frost hares, and several elegant creatures that would have made far more respectable prizes, yet Cassie’s attention landed on the otter immediately.
“That one,” she said, leaning closer to the display.
The decision formed before reason had time to become involved. Cassie looked at the otter, her expression softening with uncomplicated delight, and somewhere inside me a private law came into effect declaring that it belonged to her.
Kess followed Cassie’s gaze and then looked at me. Her smile sharpened with immediate comprehension. “Oh, no. Mira has entered a state.”
“I have not entered anything,” I said, though Naomi had already begun watching me over the rim of her cocoa with the patient concern of someone identifying the first signs of a natural disaster.
Cassie remained focused on the display. The otter’s ribbon brightened as she moved closer, either because the enchantment reacted to attention or because even stuffed animals possessed enough judgment to prefer her. “Look at its little hands. It looks like it wants to hold something.”
“I am aware of how hands function.”
Her eyes moved toward me, amusement gathering in the blue. “You like it too.”
“I have no opinion.”
The otter turned its head toward me and raised both paws.
Kess made a delighted sound that drew the attention of two people at the neighboring stall. “It knows.”
“It is enchanted merchandise,” I said. “It responds to potential customers.”
Naomi took another slow drink, which did nothing to hide the movement at the corner of her mouth. “Potential customer.”
“I am leaving,” I announced, managing less than half a step before Cassie caught my hand.
“You don’t have to win it,” she said. “I only said it was cute.”
That was precisely the problem. She had said it casually and meant it, with no expectation that I would do anything about it. The perfect date required gestures that appeared effortless, and buying the otter outright would have been too easy, possibly too obvious, and entirely lacking in romance. Winning it involved skill, determination, and the opportunity to look impressive beneath Winter lanterns. The fact that Winter had already compromised my coordination was a temporary logistical inconvenience that did not deserve the dignity of consideration.
“I know,” I said. “I want to.”
Cassie searched my face, probably measuring the distance between ordinary determination and whatever expression had taken control of mine. “Mira.”
“It is one carnival game.”
Behind the counter, the vendor looked up from arranging a row of silver tokens. He was a broad-shouldered Winter elf in a fur-lined coat, with dark eyeliner swept into points sharp enough to threaten anyone who challenged his prize distribution. “Veilball,” he announced, gesturing toward a silver line etched across the packed snow. “Three targets, three orbs. Strike all three in a single round and choose anything from the upper shelves.”
Kess clapped once and reached for her purse. “Excellent. First round is on me.”
Naomi caught her wrist before money appeared. “Do not encourage this.”
“I support romance.”
“You support escalation.”
“They frequently overlap.”
Kess managed to free one hand and slap a glittering token onto the counter before Naomi could stop her. The vendor accepted it with the solemnity of someone who had already calculated how much profit my desperation might produce.
Beyond the silver line, three crystalline birds perched upon narrow poles at varying heights. The vendor touched a control sigil, and the birds launched together, their glass wings reflecting lanternlight across the watching crowd. The first swept low before climbing abruptly. The second circled the stall sign and vanished behind it for half a breath at a time. The third darted between the others with the specific malice of something programmed to recognize emotional vulnerability.
“Do the targets always move like that?” Cassie asked.
“They adjust to the player,” the vendor said. “The more accurate the throw, the less cooperative they become.”
“That seems dishonest.”
“That is why it is called a game.”
Three spheres of compacted enchanted snow formed on the counter. Each orb was larger than my palm and cold enough to sting through the leather when I lifted it. Magic shifted inside the packed surface, waiting for motion, while I rolled my shoulder and studied the birds.
At Ravenrest, I could send a flyer rotating through the air and catch her without looking frightened. I could tumble across a mat, land on a narrow line, and adjust my body halfway through a fall before anyone else noticed the mistake. Throwing a snowball at a glass bird should not have qualified as a challenge, especially not with Cassie watching and the otter’s little paws still raised behind the vendor.
I selected the lowest target, waited until its arc flattened, and threw. The orb left my hand cleanly enough for satisfaction to rise, but the bird folded one wing and dropped beneath its path, allowing the snowball to burst harmlessly against the back curtain.
Kess winced. “Strong opening.”
“It dodged.”
“That is what the targets do.”
“I was not asking.”
The second bird circled behind the sign. I tracked it carefully, trying to account for the delay spreading through my fingers, but the cold had made them feel distant, each one responding a fraction slower than expected. I released too late. The orb clipped the sign and exploded over the vendor’s shoulder, dusting his fur collar with snow.
He brushed it away without blinking. “One remaining.”
Cassie stood just beyond the line, the otter visible over her shoulder. She did not laugh, which made the failure worse. I wanted her amused, impressed, delighted, not carefully neutral because she could see my hands beginning to shake beneath the gloves.
The third target banked left. I anticipated the movement, threw ahead of it, and watched the orb miss by less than an inch before all three birds returned to their perches and the payment sigil relit.
“Again,” I said.
Cassie touched my sleeve. “You don’t have to.”
“I know.”
Her gaze held mine for a moment. She had heard the same answer when I gave her the pastries, and she seemed to understand that I was not doing this because she demanded proof. She had wanted something, however briefly, and the wanting had become precious the moment I noticed it.
“All right,” she said, releasing my sleeve. “Again.”
I reached into my cloak and drew out Mother’s black card.
The vendor’s eyebrows rose. The polished surface carried no printed number or crest, only a thin crimson line that awakened when I pressed it against the payment sigil. The rune pulsed once, accepted the charge, and produced another set of orbs.
“Princess-level spending,” the vendor murmured.
“It is one round,” I said.
Naomi glanced toward the card. “It is now two rounds.”
“Kess paid for the first.”
“That does not improve the trajectory.”
The second attempt went worse. My first throw curved too far right, the second slipped against my glove before I had committed to the movement and struck the base of one pole hard enough to make the bird above it issue an offended chirp, and the third passed close enough to scatter frost across a crystalline tail without registering as a hit.
I swiped the card again.
By the fourth round, the vendor no longer bothered hiding his satisfaction. By the fifth, Kess had begun providing commentary from beside Naomi, though most of it involved invented statistics and accusations that the highest bird had been bribed by Autumn. The card flashed crimson after every loss, each pulse bright enough to make the vendor’s smile deepen.
My sixth attempt produced one clean hit and two humiliating misses. The first orb shattered the lowest bird into blue light, but I released the second too quickly and sent it through the edge of a neighboring stall’s enchanted snowfall. The third struck the booth sign with enough force to tilt it several degrees to the left.
Cassie looked at the sign. “You keep hitting everything except the targets.”
“The environment is crowded.”
“The environment is stationary.”
“The environment should be more careful.”
I swiped again before she could answer.
The seventh round ended with all three snowballs bursting in the air because my numb fingers sent too much magic into the first and too little into the others. The eighth produced two near misses and one orb that rolled from my palm before I threw it, crossed the silver line with painful slowness, and stopped beneath the lowest target.
Kess leaned around Naomi to watch it. “Maybe the bird will become curious.”
“It will not,” Naomi said.
The bird looked down at the orb.
Kess pointed. “It is considering it.”
I picked up the card.
“Mira,” Naomi said.
“I am aware of the number.”
“What number?”
I looked at the crimson sigil waiting beneath my hand. “The general number.”
“You have lost count.”
“I have not.”
I had.
The card pulsed again.
By what might have been the tenth round, the game had gathered a real audience. Winter courtiers paused on their way toward the lake, children crowded near the side rail, and several people from neighboring stalls had abandoned their own games to watch the Summer princess wage an increasingly personal war against three glass birds.
Their whispers slipped between the music and the chime of the targets resetting.
“She could have commissioned one.”
“It would cost less.”
“Does the High Lady know?”
“She will.”
The last comment tightened my grip on the card. Mother would know because every charge went directly through Summer’s accounts. She would receive the total, ask what I had purchased, and discover that I had spent an amount usually reserved for emergency diplomacy on an enchanted plush otter.
I swiped again.
The crimson light painted the vendor’s face. He had stopped announcing the price several rounds earlier, possibly out of mercy, though profit seemed more likely. I did not calculate the total. Arithmetic was a hostile act under emotional pressure.
The next attempt gave me two hits. The lowest bird shattered when I waited through its first dodge, and the middle one emerged from behind the sign directly into my second throw. The crowd reacted with enough enthusiasm that I rushed the third and sent it far above the highest target, where it struck a floating lantern.
The lantern sneezed violet sparks over everyone within ten feet.
Kess wiped one from her shoulder. “That counts as festive.”
“It does not count as a target,” the vendor said.
“I know what it counts as.”
I swiped again.
Cassie remained close, but the concern in her expression had sharpened. She did not tell me to stop each time I lost. That would have turned the game into a contest between us, and she knew me well enough now to avoid giving my stubbornness a second opponent. Instead, she watched my hands, my breathing, the shortening movement in my shoulder, and every pulse of Mother’s card against the sigil.
Another round passed with no hits. Then another with one. The next ended when the second orb exploded against my glove before leaving my hand, coating my sleeve in snow and making the nearest children cheer as though I had done it for them.
I bowed slightly because dignity had become too expensive to preserve.
“How many?” Cassie asked the vendor.
He looked at me.
“Do not answer that.”
Cassie’s eyes narrowed. “How many rounds?”
“Fourteen paid entries,” he said. “Fifteen including the lady’s first token.”
Kess raised one hand. “That was me. I started this.”
Naomi looked at her. “You are not helping.”
Fifteen rounds meant forty-five snowballs. I had hit six targets in total, though never three within the same attempt. The arithmetic turned ugly when I included the glowing price above the payment sigil, so I stopped before reaching a conclusion Mother would later provide at volume.
I pressed the card down again.
Cassie caught my wrist before the charge completed. “Enough for a minute.”
“I am improving.”
“You can barely close that hand.”
“I only need it to work three more times.”
“Mira.”
The way she said my name cut through the crowd more effectively than shouting would have. I looked at her and found no embarrassment in her expression. She was not worried that I looked ridiculous, though I clearly did. She was worried because Winter had leeched the color from my fingers and I was still treating pain as a fee I could pay for something she wanted.
“I can win it,” I said.
“I know you can.” Cassie slid the card from my grip before I could object and handed it to Naomi. “Come with me.”
“You stole Mother’s card.”
“I gave it to the most responsible person here.”
Naomi tucked the card inside her jacket.
Kess looked offended. “I am standing right here.”
“That was part of the calculation,” Cassie said.
She guided me toward the side of the stall where the lanterns cast more warmth and the audience had less reason to listen. Kess started after us, but Naomi caught the back of her cloak and redirected her toward the waiting crystal foxes.
“But I could help,” Kess protested.
“That has never been the concern,” Naomi said.
Cassie waited until they were out of immediate hearing range before holding out her hand. “Give me yours.”
“It is attached to my arm.”
“Mira.”
I surrendered it because my fingers had begun shaking too badly to make defiance look convincing. Cassie pulled off my glove carefully, and the air bit into my exposed skin at once. My fingers were paler than they should have been, with a faint blue tint beneath the nails. Her mouth tightened, but she did not lecture me. She wrapped both hands around mine and brought them near the front of her coat, shielding them from the wind while she rubbed warmth back into the stiff joints.
“I can keep going,” I said.
“I know.”
“You want the otter.”
“I said the otter was cute.”
“Which means you want it.”
“I also said the lanterns were beautiful. Are you going to spend Summer’s treasury trying to knock one out of the sky?”
“Not unless the game requires it.”
A laugh escaped her before she could stop it. The sound should have annoyed me, but it loosened some of the rigid pressure behind my ribs instead.
“I don’t need you to win me anything,” Cassie said, still warming my hand.
“I know.”
“You have already spent enough to purchase the booth.”
“That seems unlikely.”
“The vendor looks ready to name a child after you.”
“I am supporting Winter commerce.”
“You are losing repeatedly.”
“That is how the commerce receives support.”
Cassie looked down at our hands before lifting them slightly between us. “I already have the pastries. I have your hand. I have you standing here trying to turn a carnival game into a declaration of devotion.”
“That last part is an exaggeration.”
“You have thrown forty-five enchanted snowballs.”
I hated that she knew the number. “The targets are dishonest.”
“The targets are glass birds.”
“They know what they did.”
Her expression softened, though the worry remained beneath it. “Why does winning this matter so much?”
Because river otters were my favorite. Because Cassie had smiled at this one. Because the creature held its little paws out like trust could be stitched into fur and ribbon. Because I wanted to give her something that belonged to a part of me she did not know yet, and I wanted to do it without explaining why it mattered.
“I want you to have it,” I said.
Cassie’s thumbs moved slowly over my knuckles. “Then stop trying to beat everyone watching.”
“I am not.”
“You are listening to them.”
“I can hear them. That is not the same thing.”
“It is when every whisper makes you swipe faster.”
I looked toward the booth. The targets had settled on their perches while the vendor waited, patient in the way people became when they expected wealth to resume making mistakes. Naomi stood near the silver line with Mother’s card tucked safely away, and Kess had somehow acquired a crystal fox nearly as large as she was without playing any visible game.
Cassie shifted closer, enclosing my hand more securely between hers. “You’re treating it like cheer.”
“I am very good at cheer.”
“You’re good because you know where your body is. Right now, you don’t.”
The observation landed too accurately to dismiss. I hated that she could see it, and I hated more that she had seen it and stayed close rather than turning my weakness into an argument for stopping.
“What do you suggest?” I asked.
Cassie looked past me toward the targets. Her attention sharpened, captain replacing date in the set of her shoulders. “The lowest bird drops before the first throw reaches it. You keep aiming where it is when you release.”
“That is usually how targets work.”
“Not these. The middle one hides when your arm comes up, and the high one banks toward the sign whenever the others are hit.”
I stared at her. “You have been studying them.”
“I was watching you.”
The distinction warmed me more effectively than her hands.
Cassie slid my glove back over my fingers and fastened the wrist. “Wait longer. Let the first one dodge before you release. Don’t throw harder because you’re angry. Your strength is already enough.”
“You sound like Coach.”
“I am better dressed than Coach.”
“That is a dangerously low standard.”
“Still true.” She kept hold of my hand as we returned to the line. “One more round.”
“And if I miss?”
“Then you decide whether you want another. Not the crowd, not the vendor, and not your mother’s card. You.”
Naomi handed the card back reluctantly. “This is round sixteen.”
“Technically seventeen if we count Kess.”
“We should,” Kess said. “I deserve inclusion.”
I pressed the card to the sigil before the number could settle properly in my mind. Crimson light spread beneath my fingers, brighter than before, and the vendor placed three fresh orbs on the counter.
Cassie remained at my shoulder while the birds launched.
I raised the first orb and waited. The lowest bird dipped before I threw, exactly as Cassie predicted, then began climbing toward its original path. I released as its wings opened, and the snowball struck the center of its crystalline body.
Blue light burst across the stall while the first bell rang, bright and clean. I reached for the second orb without looking away from the targets. The middle bird vanished behind the sign as my arm came up, but instead of throwing into empty space, I held the position until it emerged on the opposite side.
The cold pulled at my shoulder. My fingers tightened too slowly around the orb, forcing me to adjust and let the bird complete another curve before I threw. The snowball struck one glass wing, and the rest of the target dissolved into silver sparks as the second bell joined the first.
Noise rose behind me. Kess shouted something encouraging and probably obscene, while Naomi told her to stop coaching. The final bird climbed higher as the other two reformed below it, circling beyond the easiest range. My heartbeat hammered against the cold, each pulse carrying too little warmth toward my hands, and the last orb sat heavy in my palm.
The bird banked toward the sign. I tracked it, but my arm had begun to tremble and the angle shifted each time my muscles tightened. Every whisper behind me sharpened until Cassie moved close enough that her coat brushed mine. She did not touch my throwing arm or try to correct my stance. Her hand settled at the center of my back, warm and steady through the cloak.
“Take your time, Firefly.”
The word entered me more cleanly than the cold ever had. I almost lowered the orb and turned toward her.
“What did you call me?”
“Win the otter and I might tell you.”
“That is coercive.”
“You like me better when I’m mean.”
I did, which was the problem with nearly everything involving Cassie Fairborn. The bird swept past the sign, climbed, and turned, while I stopped trying to force heat into numb fingers or make my body behave as though Winter had no claim on it. The cold was there. The tremor was there. Cassie’s hand remained at my back, giving me one point in the world that did not move.
I waited until the bird committed to the turn before throwing. The orb left my hand without forceful correction or last-second panic, carrying a faint thread of gold across its surface, not enough to guide it, only the weak answer of my fire following the motion. The bird tried to rise, but the snowball struck beneath one crystalline wing and exploded through its center.
All three targets shattered into light. The stall erupted into bells while Veilfire streamed from the roof in gold and silver ribbons, and the sign above the counter announced victory in letters large enough to embarrass the dead. Applause broke through the crowd, mixed with Kess’s triumphant howl and a single sharp whistle from Naomi.
I stood beneath the falling light with my throwing hand still extended, too stunned to lower it until Cassie’s palm pressed more firmly against my back.
“You did it,” she said.
“I know.”
“You sound surprised.”
“The bird was evasive.”
“You were better.”
The vendor looked less pleased than his professional obligations required. He climbed onto a narrow stool and reached toward the highest shelf, where the enchanted otter lifted its paws before he touched it, apparently willing to cooperate now that its freedom had been purchased through sixteen charges, one borrowed token, and the remaining dignity of the Summer Court.
When he placed it in my arms, warmth spread through the brown plush and into my coat. It was softer than anything had a right to be, with most of the heat concentrated beneath the glowing blue ribbon. The little paws curled around my wrist and held there with a faint magical grip, and for a moment I forgot about the spectators entirely.
Cassie leaned closer to inspect it. “It likes you.”
“It has good instincts.”
“You said you had no opinion.”
“My opinion developed.”
The otter tilted its head against my chest, and something low and contented vibrated inside it.
Cassie’s eyes widened. “Is it purring?”
“Apparently.”
“That is ridiculous.”
“Yes.”
“It may be the best thing I have ever seen.”
The answer should have made giving it away difficult. Instead, it made the choice feel more inevitable. I turned the otter so its paws faced Cassie and held it out.
Her smile faded into surprise. “Mira.”
“It is yours.”
“You just spent sixteen rounds getting humiliated by enchanted birds.”
“Seventeen if Kess receives credit.”
“You know what I mean.”
“I won it for you.”
Cassie looked from me to the otter. The blue ribbon pulsed faster between us, impatient with her failure to accept the obvious.
“You didn’t have to,” she said.
“I know.”
The answer carried more now than it had beside the pastry box or at the beginning of the game. I did not have to bake for her. I did not have to memorize the festival route, purchase her cocoa, or spend an amount of Summer money that would cause Mother to summon accountants before breakfast. Wanting to was enough.
“I wanted you to have it,” I said. “You liked it.”
Cassie accepted the otter with both hands. The moment it touched her coat, its paws curled around one of the crimson lapels and the ribbon blazed blue-white before settling into a softer glow. She pressed it against her chest, and something inside me nearly stopped.
Cassie Fairborn could make anything look intentional. Even holding a round enchanted otter in the middle of a Winter market somehow became elegant, though the creature ruined the effect by purring loudly against her collarbone.
Her laugh came out warm and startled. She looked down at it, then back at me with an openness that made every missed throw and every future financial consequence worth the cost. “I love it.”
My fire flickered beneath my ribs, barely enough to brighten the gold threaded through my dress, but Cassie saw it. Her gaze dipped toward the light before returning to my face.
“Thank you, Firefly.”
The nickname sounded different without the game between us. It was softer now, private despite the crowd, something she had found and decided belonged to me.
“Firefly?” I asked.
Cassie adjusted the otter beneath one arm and reached for my hand with the other. “Your cocoa was full of them.”
“That is not a reason.”
“You keep trying to make light for me.”
The words caught too deep. I looked toward the glowing stalls because looking at her had become dangerous.
“That sounds sentimental.”
“I can take it back.”
“No.”
Her fingers closed around mine. “Then Firefly.”
I pretended to consider the name while my traitorous magic spread another thin line of gold through the dress. “It may be acceptable in private.”
“We are standing in public.”
“No one heard.”
Kess appeared beside us carrying the crystal fox nearly as large as she was. “I heard.”
Naomi followed with the expression of someone who had spent too long supervising a natural disaster. “Everyone within three stalls heard.”
Cassie tucked the otter more securely against her side. “Then I suppose it’s too late.”
“It is not too late,” I said. “Time remains functional.”
Kess looked between the otter, Cassie’s hand in mine, and the gold still moving faintly beneath my dress. “Secret pastries, a date, a four-digit act of public humiliation, and now pet names. You two repaired things aggressively.”
I turned toward her. “You do not know the total.”
“Neither do you.”
“We are not discussing this with you.”
“You discussed terminology without me?”
“There was no discussion.”
Cassie’s thumb brushed over my knuckles. “There was a partial discussion.”
Kess looked wounded. “I have been excluded from a milestone.”
Naomi handed her the crystal fox before she could become more dramatic. “You acquired something. Focus on that.”
“I did not win it. The vendor gave it to me to leave.”
“That still counts,” Cassie said.
Kess brightened immediately. “I like her.”
“You invited her,” Naomi reminded her.
“And I was correct.”
The market path continued toward the lake, visible beyond the final row of stalls as a sheet of dark glass crowded with skaters. Music swept across it beneath the moving lanterns, faster now, inviting everyone toward the ice.
I had planned to skate, though that plan had been created by a version of me with warm joints, responsive ankles, and unrealistic faith in enchanted clothing. My throwing arm already ached, the cold had worked through my boots and settled into my toes, and the small amount of fire stirred by winning the otter was fading beneath Winter’s pressure.
Cassie followed my gaze toward the lake. “Do you skate?”
The reasonable answer was that I had skated several times as a child and had not died. The honest answer was that those experiences occurred near Summer’s borders on carefully maintained ornamental ice, with attendants, railings, and no girl I desperately wanted to impress watching from three feet away.
“I can,” I said.
Naomi’s eyes narrowed, while Kess hugged the enormous fox against her chest. “That sounded technically constructed.”
“I have skated before.”
“How long ago?” Cassie asked.
“Time is subjective.”
“It is not.”
I lifted my chin. “I said I would show you Frostfire.”
“You have.”
“We have not reached the lake.”
Cassie studied me long enough that I felt the scrutiny against every place Winter had begun hollowing out. She did not tell me no or list reasons I should stop. Instead, she shifted the otter beneath one arm and held out her free hand.
“All right, Firefly,” she said. “But I’m teaching you.”
“I do not need lessons.”
“You missed a stationary sign with a snowball repeatedly for an amount of money that is going to create legal correspondence.”
“The sign was not the target.”
“That does not improve the story.”
Naomi turned toward the lake before I could answer, and Kess followed while carrying the crystal fox like a conquered kingdom. Cassie remained beside me, the otter purring beneath one arm and her other hand still offered between us.
My perfect date had escaped the route, exposed my secret baking, acquired terminology, emptied a measurable portion of Summer’s accounts, and resulted in a stuffed animal receiving more public approval than I had. It was not remotely perfect, but Cassie was smiling at me as though none of that mattered.
I placed my hand in hers and followed her toward the ice.
novelzi